25 July 2008 @ 10:28 pm
oh, you poor dearie....
I've come to the conclusion that I have an intense dislike of the Eccentric Old Lady character so prominent in fiction of all genres. I'm sure you've encountered the type: the spinster/widow, usually accompanied by a sister or two, alternately flighty or hard as nails, always startlingly insightful, who wields tea as a Miraculous Restorative and ends---or begins---every other sentence with the words, "my dear."

Every time I meet one, I shudder. It doesn't matter how central to the plot she is. It doesn't matter if her insights actually contain some wisdom. It doesn't even matter if I'm in the mood for tea when she starts serving it. It's all I can do not to skip through her scenes. And every moment of mincing endearments, of fragrant, steamy beverages, of creaking voices and bright, twinkling eyes makes me ill.

I realize this is a little awkward, since Kettle, of my most recent short story, is in the style of an Eccentric Old Lady. Granted, she's not corporeal, which makes serving tea rather complicated, and I think she managed to keep the "my dears" to a minimum---and I rather like her. But I can only hope that my readers are not nearly as aggravated by the Eccentric Old Lady as I seem to be.
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] ludzu-alus.livejournal.com on July 26th, 2008 04:20 am (UTC)
On a completely different note... :)

Have you seen the new HC My Name is Will: A Novel of Sex, Drugs, and Shakespeare by Jess Winfield? Is funny! I enjoyed the Shakespearean double/triple entendres.

Also, the Eccentric Old Lady character doesn't bother me too much. Sometimes it can get a bit boring - it's hard to find an eccentricity that is different enough from all the other Eccentric Old Ladys' eccentricities to be interesting, but not so far out there that she goes from being the Eccentric Old Lady to the Not-Really-There-At-All-Keep-Her-Busy-Why-Don't-You-While-I-Go-Call-The-Nice-Men-With-The-White-Jacket Old Lady. But then, I really love fairy tales and without Eccentric Old Ladies/Witches/Wise Women/Fairy Godmothers there really wouldn't be fairy tales as we know them. I prefer them well-written, 'tis true.

(I really had fun writing that last paragraph.)
(Reply) (Thread) (Link)
[identity profile] in-omnia.livejournal.com on August 14th, 2008 04:43 pm (UTC)
I can tell. :) And yes, I'd seen that book---both on your book blog and during one of my periodic visits to bn.com. (In lieu of actually working among the new books everyday, I visit the website to see what's coming/new/etc. Still not the same, alas.) I shall have to add it to my list of Books To Be Read.

And I definitely see your point about fairy tales. I guess I just wish the Eccentric Old Ladies I meet in so much fiction felt as fresh and original and *necessary* as their fairy tale counterparts. So much of the time, though, they seem to be filler characters, fluttering about with pots of tea and exclamations of concern, eventually revealing that they are, in fact, Geniuses In The Know or Wise Beyond Their Eccentricities or some such. In those cases, I just want to skip the preliminaries and jump right to the packet of plot-pertinent info they have to dispense. Maybe I'll have to write a character who greets my hero/heroine at the door with a "Hullo, my dear," a cup of tea, and an envelope with all the information the hero/heroine needs to know. Whereupon the Eccentric Old Lady says, "Farewell and good journey, my dear," whisks the cup of tea away, and slams the door.
(Reply) (Parent) (Link)