29 November 2009 @ 11:28 pm
han shot first
I wish there was a way to order the original Star Wars trilogy to my own personal specifications. Episode IV was on tonight and as always, I found myself cringing at the part where Han has been edited out of shooting first. Granted, I rather like Han Solo as a practical, Wild West-type gunslinger who knows when to shoot scum-of-the-earth bounty hunters rather than get himself killed, but I think I could get behind the whole self-defense thing if it didn't look so damn stupid.

And then there's that whole editing the end of Return of the Jedi so Anakin looks like Hayden Christensen. Unlike most people I know, I actually don't mind the new end sequence---or even the new end sequence music---but replacing the Sebastian Shaw face only forces me to recall the dark times of Star Wars. And considering how much effort I've expended trying to expunge the prequels from my awareness, that seems a cruel way to end an Ewok party.

So, George Lucas, is it too much to ask that your audience be allowed to pick and choose the pieces of the three different editions you've released? Because I've been doing it myself, and in addition to being a little hard to explain, shifting back and forth between DVD and VHS just so I don't have to watch those aggravating bits is exhausting.

.........................
 
 
Prepare a Face: geeky
Love Song: Star Wars theme
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] in-omnia.livejournal.com on December 10th, 2009 11:25 pm (UTC)
That's a really good point. I hadn't articulated it, but I think the timing of Anakin's redemption was aggravating the back of my mind. I mean, Obi-Wan is his Alec Guinness self, so why shouldn't Anakin be his Sebastian Shaw self? I'm sure fans have explained that away by saying Jedi take on the form that best suits them upon their being absorbed into the Force. But I'm actually of the opinion that it's *Luke's* perception that makes the difference---the Force exists as it exists: it's Luke's eyes that "see" within it the shapes of the people he's known. And since he knew Alec Guinness' Obi-Wan and Sebastian Shaw's Anakin, that's who should be in that scene.

Maybe someday someone will be able to convince George Lucas to allow us to build our own Star Wars. But I think he might be more offended than anything at the notion that his original work is far superior to any of the edits---or prequels---he's produced since. Then again, he might not have a choice if technology keeps advancing as it has been. The fans might take the films into their own editing software and make of it what they will.... Bwahahahahahaha!
(Reply) (Parent) (Link)